Follow Us:

Asphalt Resurfacing vs. Replacement: Which Is Right for You?

It is critical for both your safety and your property’s street appeal that you keep your asphalt driveway or parking lot in good repair. Asphalt surfaces have a tendency to deteriorate over time, becoming cracked or otherwise showing indications of wear and strain. When confronted with these challenges, property owners frequently contemplate whether or not asphalt replacement or resurfacing is the superior course of action to choose. To assist you in making a well-informed choice, we will discuss the primary distinctions that exist between the two choices in this blog post.

The Resurfacing of Asphalt

Asphalt resurfacing, which is also known as overlay or resurfacing, is a method that is both efficient and cost-effective, and it allows you to refresh the look of your asphalt surface while maintaining its performance. The following is essential information regarding asphalt resurfacing:


  • Resurfacing is typically more cost-effective than a complete replacement, making it an appealing choice for individuals who are interested in lowering their overall expenditures.
  • Time-Efficient: The procedure takes less time than a total replacement would, so there will be less interruptions to your normal activities as a result.
  • Resurfacing your asphalt can give it a new, smooth surface that improves its appearance and adds to the overall appeal of your property.


  • Resurfacing is recommended for asphalt surfaces that have tiny cracks, surface-level damage, or wear and tear. However, this solution is not appropriate for all circumstances. Problems that are deeply rooted and fundamental will not be addressed by this.
  • Although resurfacing your asphalt will extend its life, you should be aware that it will not necessarily provide the same level of durability as a complete replacement.

The Replacement of Asphalt

In order to properly replace asphalt, the old asphalt surface must be completely removed before a brand new layer can be laid down from the ground up. The following are some of the most important considerations to make regarding asphalt replacement:


  • Longevity: Replacement results in a brand-new asphalt surface that has a longer lifespan than the previous one, typically lasting between 15 and 20 years or more.
  • Repairs to the Structure: This fixes any underlying structural problems, making sure that your new asphalt has a firm and steady foundation to sit on.
  • Personalization: You have the ability to select asphalt mixtures and designs from a variety of options to best meet the requirements and preferences unique to your situation.


The removal and installation of a new surface is labor-intensive and time-consuming, which drives up the cost of asphalt replacement. As a result, this choice comes with a higher price tag.

  • Time-Consuming: The procedure requires more time than resurfacing, which may result in a greater degree of annoyance for the customer.
  • Disruption It is possible that the use of the property will be disrupted while the replacement is being completed, which may have an impact on enterprises or on everyday routines.

How Should One Choose?

The state of the asphalt surface you already have, as well as your budget and the goals you have for the long run, are factors that should guide your decision between asphalt resurfacing and replacement. The following are some considerations to take into account:

Surface Condition: If your asphalt has considerable damage, deep fissures, or structural difficulties, the only realistic remedy may be to replace it.

Budget: Resurfacing is a better option for people who are wanting to save money in the near term because it is less expensive than other options. On the other hand, replacement offers superior value over the long term.

Asphalt replacement is the best option to take if you are looking for a solution that will endure for a long time and are willing to put money into it.

Goals: Think about what you want to accomplish with the asphalt surface. Resurfacing is an option worth considering if you want to give your appearance a boost in a hurry for aesthetic reasons. However, if you are seeking for a comprehensive makeover as well as changes to the structure, replacement is the option you should go with.

Consultation with a Professional It is strongly recommended that you seek the advice of a professional asphalt contractor whenever possible. They are able to evaluate the state of your asphalt and offer experienced guidance on the approach that is going to be most successful.

The final word

Asphalt resurfacing and replacement are both options that come with their own set of benefits and drawbacks. Evaluate the state of your existing asphalt, your financial situation, and your long-term aspirations to help you choose the solution that best meets your needs. It is a great step toward making an informed selection to talk things over with an asphalt contractor who is a professional. Whether you choose to resurface it or replace it, making an investment in the maintenance of your asphalt surface is the best way to guarantee that your property will have increased safety, functionality, and aesthetic appeal.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *